Media Is The New Weblog!

Throughout our class examination on Avril Lavigne, my views on her and this case of plagiarism and copyright infringement have remained fairly the same throughout our classes’ many discussions. They have, however, expanded knowledge wise and have grown in understanding of the fine details of this case.

Basically, I believe that looking at Avril’s actions and reactions during this case can be boiled down and represented with one word. Responsibility, a key factor that may have very well enabled this case to end quickly, quietly and efficiently. Though there is likely no one evident that we can place sole blame on for the violation, people will naturally base their emotions and opinions off of who and what they know. They know Avril Lavigne, and recognize “Girlfriend” as her song. Therefore, Avril has most likely become the injured party. I don’t necessarily blame the viewers for their accusations however. We’ve discussed in class the possibilities of other cases involving Avril Lavigne and other bands/singers including My Chemical Romance, and Peaches, to whom she admitted to coping their song. I believe a situation like this can be compared to cheating, try it once, you don’t get caught, everything works out perfectly. Cheating as is plagiarism is just too convenient and easy to do, and is in no way the right thing to do. From what our class has learned about this case I see a definite possibly that this song is one of Avril’s repeat offences. This time however, the law caught her. As a role model to many who are years younger, Avril hasn’t been a very good example, and if in fact she hadn’t stole the song intentionally, I believe it is her job as well as her producer’s and writer’s to take responsibility and notice that there is in fact something wrong with what had happened. Sure, everyone makes mistakes, even ones they don’t mean to make, at least own up and recognize that you did in fact slip-up.

In my opinion, the Rubinoo’s has every right to accuse Avril of plagiarism of their song “I Wanna Be Your Boyfriend”, not only because I agree with all who found obvious similarities between the two songs in the beat, lyrics, tempo etc., but because the Rubinoo’s felt there was a infringement in Avril’s song. They had obviously found similarities and needed justice and credit if she did in fact plagiarize.

Basically, anything was possible in this case. I do believe Avril Lavinge to be guilty of copyright infringement and do believe that she got lucky by getting away with it. I hope that because of this incident she realized that it is possible for you to get caught and she returns to individual and her own creative writing, from her own feelings and soul, the way all music should be.